Home Internet of Things Aerospace Apparel Energy Defense Health Care Logistics Manufacturing Retail

Patent Lawsuit Not a Major Issue for RFID

A company known as Round Rock Research is suing some users of EPC RFID technology, but the industry is addressing the matter in its usual way.
By Mark Roberti
Should you wait until it is settled before launching an RFID project? I don't think so. In fact, I know of no one who has shelved a project or slowed its deployment as a result of this lawsuit.

That's because this is a normal—if unpleasant—part of the technology business. Young RFID Journal readers might not remember that Apple sued Microsoft over the first version of Windows, when Microsoft made the switch from DOS to a graphical-user interface. In the mid-1990s, a technology company called Integraph sued Intel over its use of chip designs. Intel eventually paid Intergraph $224 million to settle the case. In 2003, a company known as SCO sued IBM, Novell, Red Hat and Daimler Chrysler, claiming that its proprietary software code had been misappropriated and incorporated into the Linux operating system.

Even within the automatic-identification technology sector, this is nothing new. When bar-code technology was gaining widespread acceptance, inventor Jerome H. Lemelson sued Symbol Technologies, Intermec Technologies, Metrologic Instruments, Teklogic, Zebra Technologies, Telxon and other manufacturers of bar-coding equipment, claiming they were infringing on his mid-1950s patents for machine-vision technologies. Lemelson's estate sued some users of bar-code technology—Walmart, Sears and The Home Depot—after he passed away in 1997. The courts eventually threw out the lawsuits, and manufacturers of bar-code technologies did not have to pay royalties to license the patents.

How will this court case turn out? It's impossible to know for sure, as U.S. patent cases are a crapshoot. But I would say that one of two outcomes is likely. Either the Round Rock claims will be thrown out, in which case everyone will be off the hook, or the RFID technology providers will negotiate a royalty to Round Rock. If the latter happens, that will have a marginal impact on equipment costs, but it is unlikely the royalty will be so high that it will affect deployments (that would be against Round Rock's interest, after all, since if no one used the technology, the company would earn no royalties).

Lawsuits, particularly within the United States, are part of the introduction of new technologies. There are processes for working out these issues, but they unfortunately take a long time to play out. Meanwhile, there is no need to sit and wait for every question to be answered before proceeding with an RFID deployment. Eventually, this issue will be settled, and RFID will proliferate.

Mark Roberti is the founder and editor of RFID Journal. If you would like to comment on this article, click on the link below. To read more of Mark's opinions, visit the RFID Journal Blog, the Editor's Note archive or RFID Connect.

Login and post your comment!

Not a member?

Signup for an account now to access all of the features of RFIDJournal.com!

Case Studies Features Best Practices How-Tos
Live Events Virtual Events Webinars
Simply enter a question for our experts.
RFID Journal LIVE! RFID in Health Care LIVE! LatAm LIVE! Brasil LIVE! Europe RFID Connect Virtual Events RFID Journal Awards Webinars Presentations