Home Internet of Things Aerospace Apparel Energy Defense Health Care Logistics Manufacturing Retail

Access This Premium Content

Options To Access This Article:

What Subscribers Are Saying

  • "Probably the best investment I've ever made."
    Steve Meizlish, President & CEO, MeizCorp Services, Inc.
  • "I have found that RFID Journal provides an objective viewpoint of RFID. It you are looking for a resource that provides insights as to the application and implications of deploying RFID, RFID Journal will meet your needs, It gives you a broad perspective of RFID, beyond the retail supply chain."
    Mike O'Shea, Director of Corporate AutoID/RFID Strategies & Technologies, Kimberly-Clark Corp.
  • "No other source provides the consistent value-added insight that Mark Robert and his staff do. In a world dominated by press release after press release, RFID Journal is developing as the one place to go to make the most sense out of the present and future of RFID in commerce."
    Bob Hurley, Project Leader for RFID, Bayer HealthCare's Consumer Care Division
  • "RFID Journal is the one go-to source for information on the latest in RFID technology."
    Bruce Keim, Director, Hewlett-Packard
  • "RFID Journal is the only source I need to keep up to the minute with the happenings in the RFID world."
    Blair Hawley, VP of Supply Chain, Remington Products Company

Courting Confusion

Will Round Rock Research's RFID patents be validated?
By Mark Roberti
Aug 01, 2012—Late last year, a patent-licensing company called Round Rock Research launched a barrage of lawsuits against end users of RFID technology, including American Apparel, Dole Food, Fruit of the Loom, Hanesbrands, JCPenney, Macy's, PepsiCo., Gap and VF Corp. The suits claim these companies are infringing on five U.S. patents relating to the use of ultrahigh-frequency RFID tags and readers. Round Rock acquired these patents—numbers 5,500,650, 5,627,544, 5,974,078, 6,459,726 and Re 41,531—from Micron Technology, a semiconductor company.

Other end users have received cease-and desist-letters from Round Rock, claiming plans to use RFID would violate Round Rock's patents. Round Rock was founded by John Desmarais, a patent attorney who became famous when he won a $1.52 billion verdict for Alcatel-Lucent against Microsoft in 2007. Round Rock is going after end users rather than technology providers, perhaps because they have more money and are more likely to settle and pay a licensing fee for the patents (settling could be cheaper than a long, drawn- out court fight).

In March, Motorola Solutions, a provider of RFID technology, filed a countersuit against Round Rock. According to Motorola's complaint, the company was asked to defend the retailers being sued, because Motorola had indemnified them in contracts signed when the retailers purchased the technology. Motorola is seeking a declaratory judgment that its RFID products do not infringe on the five patents, and that Round Rock's patent claims are invalid.

An anonymous party has requested reexamination of the patents, a process by which the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office reviews a patent that already has been issued, to verify the patent's claims and scope. Round Rock's lawyers have responded by requesting that the company be allowed to add more patents to the original complaints, a source told RFID Journal. The judge has not yet ruled on these motions.

Some end users are now demanding that any RFID contract they sign include an indemnification clause. Companies that provide RFID solutions based on GS1's UHF Electronic Product Code air-interface protocol standard are looking for guidance from GS1. GS1 conducted extensive patent research when it developed the Gen 2 EPC standard, and requested companies with intellectual property used in the standard make it available without a license. Many companies did this, but Micron never ventured into the UHF RFID market. It worked out a deal, instead, with Round Rock.

If Round Rock patents are validated, legal sources say, there are several ways forward. End users could be required to pay Round Rock a licensing fee, or solution providers could negotiate deals with Round Rock, in which the solution provider would pay a licensing fee in exchange for Round Rock agreeing not to sue its customers. If the patent claims are found invalid, the issue will go away—until another patent-licensing company holding RFID patents decides to try the same trick.
To continue reading this article, please log in or choose a purchase option.

Option 1: Become a Premium Member.

One-year subscription, unlimited access to Premium Content: $189

Gain access to all of our premium content and receive 10% off RFID Reports and RFID Events!

Option 2: Purchase access to this specific article.

This article contains 468 words and 1 page. Purchase Price: $19.99

Upgrade now, and you'll get immediate access to:

  • Case Studies

    Our in-dept case-study articles show you, step by step, how early adopters assessed the business case for an application, piloted it and rolled out the technology.

    Free Sample: How Cognizant Cut Costs by Deploying RFID to Track IT Assets

  • Best Practices

    The best way to avoid pitfalls is to know what best practices early adopters have already established. Our best practices have helped hundreds of companies do just that.

  • How-To Articles

    Don’t waste time trying to figure out how to RFID-enable a forklift, or deciding whether to use fixed or mobile readers. Our how-to articles provide practical advice and reliable answers to many implementation questions.

  • Features

    These informative articles focus on adoption issues, standards and other important trends in the RFID industry.

    Free Sample: Europe Is Rolling Out RFID

  • Magazine Articles

    All RFID Journal Premium Subscribers receive our bimonthly RFID Journal print magazine at no extra cost, and also have access to the complete online archive of magazine articles from past years.

Become a member today!

RFID Journal LIVE! RFID in Health Care LIVE! LatAm LIVE! Brasil LIVE! Europe RFID Connect Virtual Events RFID Journal Awards Webinars Presentations